On Monday morning, British Petroleum (BP), listed on the U.S. stock exchanges, saw a significant premarket rise of 6%. This dramatic uptick in stock value is largely attributed to a reported increase in shareholding by Elliott Investment Management, an activist investor known for its proactive approach in reshaping underperforming companiesBP stands at a crucial juncture in its corporate journey, facing the influence of one of the most aggressive investors in the global market.

Elliott Investment Management, under the leadership of Paul Singer, holds a considerable stake in this UK energy giantThe investment firm's reputation precedes it, often serving as a harbinger for change that can propel companies towards strategic pivots, changes in leadership, or even corporate breakupsOver the years, Elliott has been instrumental in initiating transformative measures across many large publicly-traded companies, a practice that has often yielded lucrative returns for its investors.

This recent move from Elliott comes on the heels of BP’s turbulent 15-year history, marked by notable missteps including the infamous Deepwater Horizon oil spill and the abrupt termination of former CEO Bernard Looney due to personal misconductUnder Looney’s leadership, BP had made sweeping commitments to a transition towards renewable energy, aiming to position itself as a leader in the global shift towards sustainability.

However, post-2020, BP has experienced a downturn in its valuation against its peers, worsened by what many consider miscalculations regarding peak oil consumption and a naive assessment of the speed at which the world would pivot towards net-zero emissionsRumors have surfaced that some of BP’s competitors are contemplating acquisitions of the beleaguered energy company, an indication of the depths to which BP's stock price has fallen.

In the past five years, BP’s stock price has declined nearly 8%, while its closest rivals, Shell and TotalEnergies, have seen their stock prices ascend by about one-third

Advertisements

The implications of this lag in performance are stark, and insiders reveal Elliott's determination to instigate transformative changes aimed at unlocking shareholder value, which they argue has been critically undermined.

Elliott's representatives have refrained from commenting publically on their intentions or the exact size of their current stake in BPHowever, previous engagements by the firm suggest that CEO Murray Auchincloss could soon face intensified scrutiny.

Auchincloss stepped into the leadership role following Looney’s sudden exit and was appointed as CEO in January 2024 after initially acting in the position since September 2023. Since assuming control, Auchincloss, the former CFO, has taken a measured approach, focusing on internal restructuring while limiting his presence in public discussions.

He has secured access to some of the biggest oil reserves across the Middle East and has initiated the divestiture of renewable energy assets, alongside a recent commitment to reduce the company’s formal workforce by approximately 5%. These steps suggest a strategic retreat from Looney’s vision of de-carbonization and a return to core business focus.

Despite these efforts, analysts and investors express skepticism regarding their sufficiencyThey voice concerns over a dwindling window for effective company restructuring, particularly with a pivotal strategic update expected later this monthHowever, BP's investor day event has been postponed by two weeks to February 26, due to Auchincloss's planned medical procedure, and is set to take place in London instead of New York.

Analysts, such as Biraj Borkhataria from Royal Bank of Canada, suggest that this moment could serve as a watershed for BP's initially proposed energy transition strategy introduced in 2020. He notes that the macro assumptions underpinning that strategy have proven inaccurate, resulting in misallocated capital and ultimately eroding the company's profit potential.

Auchincloss is anticipated to refocus BP's attention towards its core oil and gas operations, and away from renewable energy initiatives

Advertisements

However, doubts persist about the company’s ability to swiftly shift course and whether investors still possess the patience required for this turnaround.

Elliott, of course, is unlikely to adopt a wait-and-see strategyWith a myriad of methods at its disposal to drive a faster transformation, the firm could exert significant influence over BP's strategic direction.

Since Looney's departure, BP's management team and board have seen scant turnover, which potentially places their leadership directly in Elliott’s crosshairsThe chairman, Helge Lund, along with Looney, has faced criticism as one of the architects behind the company’s net-zero aspirations.

Borkhataria stated, “Given BP’s underperformance relative to its peers … we believe any activist investor would at least demand a change in the board chairman.” This sentiment reflects a broader trend where Elliott has successfully urged corporate breakups in other companies, leveraging BP's size and scale for potential separation opportunitiesHowever, the intricate integration of BP's core oil and gas operations–spanning from the wellhead all the way to refineries and gas stations, backed by a globally coordinated trading team–makes any division a particularly complex endeavor.

The clearest path for disaggregation lies between the clean energy and fossil fuels sectors, a process already partially underway under Auchincloss's stewardshipRecent announcements revealed that BP intends to spin off its offshore wind business into a joint venture while pursuing divestment of its onshore wind assets.

BP retains complete ownership of its solar and battery-storage segment, Lightsource, branded as “the engine of onshore renewable energy,” reflecting a strategic focus similar to its current push to divest from onshore wind farms in the U.S.

The company also runs an electric vehicle charging segment that gained momentum after its successful acquisition of TravelCenters of America for $1.3 billion in 2023. BP has aims to expand its EV charging infrastructure significantly, planning to install over 100,000 charging points globally by 2030, building upon its existing network of 37,500 chargers worldwide.

While Elliott’s intentions remain clouded, it is apparent that as conversations evolve, the pressure for transformative moves at BP may soon escalate

Advertisements

Last Tuesday saw BP announce its fourth-quarter financial performance amid generally disappointing results across its broader operations—echoing trends seen in other oil majors facing a tough marketNevertheless, BP's particularly weak balance sheet has necessitated a slowdown in stock buybacks, undermining a critical tool that has kept investors content in prior years.